Why your 30s fitness strategy stops working after 40

Buenos días, I hope you feel great!

Let me start with a question you might be asking yourself:

Thanks for reading Yessica's Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

“Why doesn’t this work anymore?”

If you’re between 35-50, doing yoga, Pilates, intermittent fasting, eating clean—basically everything you’re “supposed” to do—and your body composition is still shifting...

You’re not alone. And there´s definitely nothing wrong with you. Your body just changed the rules.

Here’s what the research shows (and what I see with clients every week):

Starting at age 30, you begin losing 3-5% of muscle mass per decade (Evans, 2010).

In your early 30s? You probably don’t notice. Hormones are still strong. Recovery is quick. Your usual habits keep working.

But after 40? Everything accelerates.

Particularly during perimenopause (women, typically 40-52) or andropause (men, starting around 40), your body undergoes fundamental changes:

→ Muscle loss speeds up (up to 8% per decade)
→ Metabolism drops 2-4% per decade
→ Hormones shift (estrogen decreases, testosterone decreases) reducing your body’s ability to build muscle
→ “Anabolic resistance” develops — your muscles become less responsive to protein and training
→ Stress sensitivity increases — what used to be manageable becomes counterproductive

Let’s be specific about what stops working (and why):

Yoga and Pilates alone: Incredible for mobility, stress management, and body awareness—but they don’t provide enough mechanical tension to maintain muscle mass as you age.

Intermittent fasting after 40: Can increase cortisol in already stress-sensitive bodies, promoting muscle breakdown instead of fat loss (Hutchison et al., 2019). What helped you lean out in your 30s might be working against you now.

Light weights, high reps: Doesn’t provide sufficient stimulus to preserve muscle. Your body needs progressive overload—real, challenging resistance.

Cardio-focused training: Great for cardiovascular health, but doesn’t build the muscle your metabolism desperately needs to maintain itself.

Undereating or severe calorie restriction: Compounds the problem by signaling your body to preserve fat and break down muscle. The opposite of what you want.

Here’s what research (and real-world results) consistently show:

1. Progressive strength training with sufficient load

After 40, you need to lift heavier than you think you can (safely, with proper form).

Research shows resistance training at greater than 70% of your one-rep max is essential for maintaining muscle mass as anabolic signaling decreases (Straight et al., 2019).

Translation: Stop doing just light weights. Your body needs real mechanical challenge.

Practical application:
→ 3 times per week minimum
→ Compound movements (squats, deadlifts, hip thrusts, presses, rows)
→ Progressive overload (gradually increasing weight or reps)
→ 48-72 hours recovery between training the same muscle groups

2. Optimized protein intake

Your protein needs increase as you age, not decrease.

Why? Anabolic resistance. Your muscles become less responsive to protein signals, so you need more protein per meal to trigger muscle protein synthesis.

Research-backed targets:
→ 1.6-2.2g protein per kg of body weight daily (Burd et al., 2013)
→ 30-40g protein per meal for people over 40 (Pennings et al., 2012)
→ Distributed throughout the day, not just one big meal

Example: If you weigh 70kg, you need 112-154g protein daily, split across 3-4 meals.

Practical sources:
→ Breakfast: 2 eggs + Greek yogurt + protein smoothie = 35-40g
→ Lunch: Chicken breast or fish (150g) + quinoa = 35-40g
→ Dinner: Lean beef or tofu (150g) + legumes = 35-40g

3. Strategic nutrition timing

After 40, especially during hormonal transitions, long fasting windows can backfire.

Recent research on women´s physiology is clear on this: “Stop the long fasting windows after 40.”

Your body needs consistent fuel to:
→ Build and maintain muscle
→ Support metabolic function
→ Manage stress hormones
→ Maintain energy throughout the day

What works better:
→ Protein-rich breakfast within 1-2 hours of waking
→ Balanced meals every 3-4 hours
→ Pre- and post-workout nutrition
→ Prioritizing recovery over restriction

4. Adequate recovery

Your recovery needs increase with age, but you can’t afford to skip training sessions either.

The balance:
→ 48-72 hours between heavy training for the same muscle groups
→ 7-9 hours quality sleep (non-negotiable)
→ Active recovery days (walking, gentle yoga, mobility work)
→ Stress management practices

Think of recovery as part of the training protocol, not something separate.

A client came to me at 47—a high-achieving professional, managing a demanding career, doing “everything right” with her health.

Her routine:
→ Yoga 5 times per week
→ Intermittent fasting 16:8
→ Eating clean, mostly plant-based
→ Walking 10,000 steps daily

Her reality:
→ Progressively weaker despite consistent effort
→ Body composition shifting (losing muscle, gaining soft tissue)
→ Energy crashing by 2pm
→ Sleep disrupted
→ Frustrated and confused

What we changed:

✓ Added progressive strength training 3 times per week
✓ Increased protein from 60g to 120g daily (30-40g per meal)
✓ Stopped fasting, implemented protein-rich breakfast
✓ Kept yoga 2 times per week for mobility and what she loved

Results after 12 weeks:

✓ Deadlift: 20kg to 60kg (200% strength increase)
✓ Body composition: lost 5kg fat, gained 3kg muscle
✓ Visible muscle definition replacing soft tissue
✓ Energy stable throughout entire day
✓ Sleep quality dramatically improved
✓ Mood and stress resilience better than in years

Her words: “I feel like I´m eating and working-out with my body now - instead of battling its changes.¨

If you’re between 35-50 and recognizing yourself in this newsletter, here’s your roadmap:

This week:

This month:

This Q:

Here’s what I want you to understand:

You’re not failing. You’re not lazy. You’re not broken.

You’re just using strategies designed for a different version of your body.

The same discipline that makes you successful in other areas of your life is sufficient.

The strategy just needs updating.

And the earlier you make this shift (late 30s vs waiting until 50 makes a huge difference), the easier the transition.

Yes, you’ll see changes in how you look. But that’s not the real story.

Muscle mass after 40 determines:

→ Metabolic health — muscle is your body’s primary site for glucose disposal
→ Bone density — resistance training is the most effective osteoporosis prevention
→ Cognitive function — directly correlated with muscle mass (Sui et al., 2016)
→ Independence and longevity — muscle mass is one of the strongest predictors of healthy aging
→ Injury prevention — strong muscles protect joints and connective tissue
→ Energy and mood — muscle tissue produces neurotransmitters that affect mental health

This isn’t vanity. This is longevity, quality of life, and sustained performance.

Hit reply and tell me:

What fitness strategy worked perfectly for you in your 20s or early 30s that doesn’t work the same way now?

I read every response, and your answers help me create content that actually serves your real challenges.

Training: Working on increasing the weight of my Bulgarian Split Squats while maintaining mobility in quadriceps and glutes - finding that sweet spot between strength and range of motion.

Reading: Built to Move. By Kelly and Juliet Starett.

Listening: Hormone and fertility experts: dangers of not having a period. Fasting can backfire for women. By Diary of a CEO.

Experimenting with: Different lifting strategies for women afraid to bulk up. Seeing remarkable differences in energy and recovery when we optimize the weight lifted and nutrition timing.

Reflecting on: How the same discipline that helps you excel professionally can transform your health—once you understand the actual variables at play.

Loving the cooler October weather for outdoor training sessions. If you’re in Madrid and want to train outside before winter hits, let’s talk. There’s something special about lifting in Retiro or Parque del Oeste as the leaves change colours.

Until next week,

Keep moving mindfully,

Yessica

Founder, Mahalo Moves Holistic movement & well-being for high performers

Mahalo Moves | mahalomoves.com

Work with me:
→ 1:1 Personal training
→ Corporate wellness programs
→ Custom workshops & events

Connect: LinkedIn | Instagram